From PPI
(Difference between pages)
Jump to: navigation, search
m (Add Category)
 
m (Update category)
 
Line 1: Line 1:
<noinclude> [[Category:PPI:Minutes]] </noinclude>
::'''Agenda PPI BOARD MEETING'''
=Board Meeting - 17.12.2018 - 21h00 CEST=


==Convened==
::'''--- [12/02/21:00]h CEST ---'''
:: Mumble: mumble.piratenpartei-nrw.de
:: Room: "/international/pirate parties international/board meeting"
:: Audio recording:
:: Video:


'''''Note : as some board members and alternate board members did not register on Congressus before the meeting, they are not appearing on the lists bellow.'''''
== Record of the meeting ==
== 1 - ATTENDEES ==
=== 1.1 - Members of the PPI board  ===


* Board :  
::participating: Bailey, Ray, Mike, Keith, Etienne, Ladislav
::excused:
::unexcused:


** Alternate board members :
=== 1.2 - Others ===
*** Cedric
:Alternate Board Members
*** kittyhundal
*** DanPrazeresBR


** Board members :  
::participating: Cédric Levieux, Kitty
*** Etienne
::excused:
*** keithgoldstein
::unexcused:
*** BaileyL
*** RayJohansen
*** MichalGill


==Absent==
:Guests
::participating:Koen
:::
:::


* Board :
== 2 - PROCEEDINGS  ==
** Alternate board members :  
:RoP:         http://wiki.pp-international.net/PPI_Board/Rules_of_Procedure
** Board members :  
* Board delegatives members :  


=Ordre du jour=
:Meeting opened at  21:08 CEST by Bailey
:Meeting chaired by Bailey
:Secretary for this meeting is Etienne


:Quorum established with 6 out of 7 board members present.
:Streaming started: not possible
:Recording started: No record, the bot is down. We are running test on Discord.
:Postal votes:
:Notes on meeting process


==PROCEEDINGS==
* [HH:MM] CEST: (name) entered the meeting [=> Quorum not established with X out of Y board members]
* [HH:MM] CEST: (name) left the meeting [=> Quorum established with X out of Y board members]
* [HH:MM] x-minute break by initiated by (name)
:Meeting closed at HH:MM CEST by (name)


Board Rules of Procedure : http://wiki.pp-international.net/PPI_Board/Rules_of_Procedure
== 3 - APPROVAL ON THE MINUTES ==


===Chair and secretary===
*Minutes of the last meeting
:https://wiki.pp-international.net/wiki/index.php?title=PPI_Minutes_2018_11_19


<div id="magicdomid33" class=""><span class="">Meeting opened at 21:08 CEST by Bailey</span></div><div id="magicdomid34" class=""><span class="">Meeting chaired by Bailey</span></div><div id="magicdomid35" class=""><span class="">Secretary for this meeting is Etienne</span></div>
::YES: Ray, Etienne, Bailey, Mike, Kitty, Ladislav
::NO:
::ABSTENTIONS:


<span class="">Streaming started: xxx</span><span class=" url"></span></div><div id="magicdomid39" class=""><span class="">Recording started: 21:08<br></span></div><div class=""><br><span class=""><span class="author-a-z65zb7s7clwcoz68zz90zb1pz90z url">https://owncloud.ag-technik.de/owncloud/index.php/s/jjk4RkeGdd9skQT</span></div>
:Minutes approved? Minutes approved


===Quorum===
:Ray : Keith signaled that Kitty should vote on his behalf because he is not able to do so.
:Bailey : Ok noted on the minutes


Establishing quorum. <br>
== 4 - REPORTS ==
{{CC|Quorum established with 5 out of 7 board members present. }}
=== 4.1 - Short report of the board members 1) ===
:Etienne: Guillaume is excused.
:Ladislav, absent not excused </br>


:Etienne: Koen and Bastian are here
* ''Board:''


==APPROVAL ON THE MINUTES==
* Guillaume: absent


Link of the last minutes :https://etherpad.pp-international.net/p/december-17-2018-xn2s040
* Bailey: Rico Brouwer from the Utrecht Pirate Party (PPNL) approached Ray and I about PPI collaborating on a project with them. The project is about political prisoners in Catalonia and raising awareness about their trials in January 2019...if you've been following the situation there, you probably know that a lot of activists and elected officials from Catalonia have faced repression and imprisonment by the Spanish government for holding an independence referendum. This is not about anyone's stance on Catalan independence but about the right to self-determination. The point is to use the global Pirate network to spread information that the media is largely ignoring. We published Rico's message to all Pirates on our website: https://pp-international.net/2018/11/call-to-action-dutch-pirates-challenge-the-international-community-to-promote-the-plight-of-catalan-political-prisoners/


{{RCBox-green|<center>:'''Approval on the minutes'''</center>
* Keith: Working on our working groups for affiliation fees and conferences, i am also trying to prepare a grant request through unhq. I am hoping to hear more about grants from unog that guillaume and bjorn should update us on. Also, i plan to attend the psc meeting sometime soon and wait to hear about that from alex kohler.
:The minutes of the last meeting are approved :


:'''YES:''' Mike, Bailey, Ray, Etienne, Keith
* Ladislav: Had TT4 discussion with Keith and Mike; started steps towards participations of PPI in the next ECOSOC meeting (mid Februrary 2019) - registration by January 2019.
:'''NO:'''
:'''ABSTENTIONS:'''
<center>{{CC|Minutes approved}}</center>}}


==REPORTS==
* Raymond: Buisness as usual. Did an interveiw with PPNL posdcast beside Bailey. Worked on PPNL Catalonia effort. Chilled and recouperated. Took part in GA/Council meeting for PPEU on behalf of PPNO. Will have the PPNO GA Thursday to Sunday. Developed a plan for a Standing Commitee for Membership data. Will be shared with the board probably next board meeting. Blog post on Catalonia: https://pp-international.net/2018/11/call-to-action-dutch-pirates-challenge-the-international-community-to-promote-the-plight-of-catalan-political-prisoners/


<div>Reports order : <br></div><div><ul><li>Board : Guillaume, Bailey, Keith, Ladislav, Ray, Mike, Etienne</li><li>Alternate : Daniel, Gregory, Kitty, Cédric <br></li></ul></div> </br>
* Mike: Worked wth Keith and Ladislav on the TT4 proposition for the PPCZ board, along with other tasks on the same subject (Keith's work group), and an e-mail draft for our members concerning the affiliation fees (my work group) both will be dealt with in detail below. Also introduced by Keith to the intricacies of being a treasurer and to all the tables and pages on the topic. :-)


:'''BaileyL''': There is the Catalonia project. Keith, Ray and I attende the meeting for the pirate security conference.</br>
* Etienne : The Rules of procedures for the Statutes Revision Standing committee are ready. I'll prepare an e-mail for the pp-leaders asking to register their delegates before the end of the month.The goal is to organize the first meeting before the 15th of January. The date will be imposed for this first meeting and after we'll set up a calendar according to the geofraphical situation of the delegates. The goal is to use meeting only to finalize the asynchronous discussions that will be hold on Discourse and (I hope) on Congressus too.
--> https://docs.google.com/document/d/13Aru7Qf9VxRFqsz4JziOw7B682d1_O97_tWWRC5okg8/edit?usp=sharing
New contact email for PPFR : international[at]partipirate.org


:'''RayJohansen''': Business as usual. Same that Bailey about the PCS. I won't be very active before the end of the year.</br>
* ''Alternates:''


:'''RayJohansen''': Business as usual. Also under the weather so my activity level will be low until the turn of the year.</br>
* Daniel : Absent


:'''MichalGill''': Same for me, I won't be available before the end of the year. I do not send the email yet.</br>
* Gregory: Absent


:'''Etienne''': Nothing new on my side. Sorry. </br>
* Kitty Nothing to report at this time.  


:'''kittyhundal''': Nothing to report. I'll be involved on Ray's prject. I'd be happy to participate to the Catalonia project.</br>
* Cédric Levieux : Waiting from Bastian for some credential on the Congressus VM, we miss the pgp key ciphering process (wrong/old key used). Communication problem, that's all.


:'''Cedric''': I installed Congressus. I've full access to the VM. I do my part, I'll upgrade Congressus and I'll inform soon.  
== 5 - Proposal No. 1 ==
:We translated in French the call for Catalonia project. </br>
*Updates from Working Groups


:'''keithgoldstein''': i've been working on UN report for elder people that we need to do quicky. I work on TT4 and PSC.  
**PSC
We have to sign up our permanent representatives for UN meeting in NY, Vienna and Geneva. </br>
:Bailey and Keith are waiting for the meeting invitation from the PSC team. We were told that we would hear about this at the beginning of December so it should be any day now.  


==1. TECH ISSUES==
:Keith : Go PSC. I also heard that the deadline for submissions to speak at psc will probably be extended. So there is still time to make submissions.


<div>Points under this item : <br></div><div><ul><li>Give an access to the Information System to Credric</li><li>Any issues remaining to enable Congressus installation</li><li>Functioning of the mailinglists (MO-5 2015 GA)<br></li></ul></div>
**TT4
:Letter from PPI to PPCZ
:Current Proposal of the Letter


"Dear Board of the Czech Pirate Party,


===Give an access to the Information System to Cedric===
We propose the continuation of the Think Twice Conference (TT4) to take place in Prague during the fall of 2019. Initial brainstorming discussions were held with relevant stakeholders, and there is positive feedback about this proposal. This letter represents an informal proposal to be approved by your board, which will allow us to commence planning of the event. Please feel free to share this document with your colleagues, as we wish to collaborate and receive feedback about structuring this event. The ideas presented below represent our initial pitch, and we will revise them accordingly. The following letter includes notes from the brainstorming session conducted by our current initial committee, which is composed of requests for support.


<div class=""><span class="">Give an access to the Information System to Cedric Levieux for Congressus installation and maintenance</span></div><div id="magicdomid91" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/399
I. Planning Committee: We plan to establish a committee with three subcommittees (below) to spearhead the organization of the event. We encourage the Czech Pirate Party to spread the word amongst its members to join the Planning Committee.
</span><span class=""></span></div><div class=""><br></div><div class=""><span class="">Note : This should be about introductions, tutorials, or other news concerning our decision to experiment with Congressus</span></div><div id="magicdomid93" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class=""><span class="">Person in charge : Cedric</span></span></span><br><span class=""></span><span class=" url"></span></div>


:RayJohansen: Resolved, and as such needs not be discussed, right?
Within the committee we will require three subcommittees: 1) The academic committee, 2) The technical support group, and 3) The logistics team
:Cedric: We need, in my point to view to make a post-mortem, because I really had a bad experience ...
:Cedric: I was vexed by Bastian during the process. I was really hard to go forward. Please be kind with people, we all do mistakes.
:BaileyL: Thank you to Cédric and Bastian. Cédric did a really great job.
:Bastian : Lot of issues, I'm not discuting those issues with all board. If I've a tech issues, I'll clear that with my colleage. I'm quite upset about what Cedric just said but we'll have to speak about this later.


===Any issues remaining to enable Congressus installation===
1) The academic committee will review submissions, decide on which submissions are accepted, provide written correspondence to speakers, moderate panel discussions, and organize the written submissions into publishable proceedings.


<div id="magicdomid99" class=""><span class="">Any issues remaining to enable Congressus installation: public key, subdomain, encryption of credentials, etc.</span></div><div id="magicdomid100" class=""><span class=""></span><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/400</span></div><div id="magicdomid102" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class=""><span class="">Person in charge</span></span></span> : Cédric<br></span></div>
2) The technical support group will be in charge of recording equipment, streaming the conference online, setting up microphones, speakers, etc.,


:Cedric: Only few upgrade to make to have full functionality between discord and congressus, explain more what is the personae part for delegation between members
3) The logistics team will coordinate human resources, fundraising, finances, press releases, translations, the details such as name tags, and all other matters to facilitate a smooth conference.


===Functioning of the mailinglists (MO-5 2016 GA)===
The following people are the current Committe Members on behalf of the PPI: Michal Gill, Ladislav Koubek, Keith Goldstein, Gregory Engels, Koen De Voegt


<div id="magicdomid201" class=""><span class="">Functioning of the mailinglists (MO-5 2016 GA)</span></div><div id="magicdomid202" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/372</span></div><div id="magicdomid203" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Person in charge : None</span></span></div><div id="magicdomid204" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-style: italic;"><span class="">
II. Content: We request recommendations about content, which will be debated by the TT4 Planning Committee in conjunction with the boards of PPCZ and PPI.


Note : Also, Keith would like to again propose uniting the PPI discussion and PP-Leaders email addresses, and I think we need to make an announcement that users who wish to write to the group now need to use the email pp-leaders@groups.pp-international.net  ***GROUPS</span></span></div>
III. Facilities: We are considering the venue and facilities necessary for this event. We consider using the new Pirate Center opened in downtown Prague, which could be used for the smaller events (capacity approx 60-80 people). As in previous TT events, we are also considering a large one day event that will be open to the public, which would be held at a larger venue or public space that should be arranged. Considerations about the venues will be made in line with the initial financing procured for the event, along with the number of registrations received for speakers and attendees.
(Ladislav: Keith, Mike I would like to speak with you regarding the wording of this paragraph prior to Mike sending it.)


:keithgoldstein: I have a point for this task. I asked before about combining pp-leaders and pp-discussion, and we did not, but it seems to me there are many people who for whatever reason signed up for pp-discussions and not pp-leaders, and we should combine these lists, because no one uses pp-leaders.discussion.
We would appreciate any input on the topics mentioned in this letter and above all, we hope for your general approval of the event to even take place in your country. We are convinced that an established international conference of this kind will benefit both the Czech Pirate Party as well as the PPI.
:BaileyL: I second that. I've heard about good argument for not doing it.  


{{CC|Keith will fix this.}}</br>
Sincerely,
:Bastian : I can put people on the same ML. We have to care for the needs of the members. We need to ask people before to delete them. </br>
:keithgoldstein: the groups. is important. before you did not have to use groups. , so it is important that everyone knows that. i will clarify in an email.
:exactly. we are just going to combine the mailing lists.
:We are not going to throw them away.
:I am just going to send all pp-leaders emails to both mailing lists.


==2. FINANCIAL ISSUES==
The Board of PPI"


<div>Points under this item : <br></div><div><ul><li>Collection of Affiliation Fees Due in 2018</li><li>Provinding Invoices For Payment</li><li>Affiliation fees that are due to be paid before the end of 2019</li><li>Budget</li><li>Cashiers</li></ul><div><br></div></div>
:Ray: So, I don't think board are the place to do working on wordings. We should ready the document before hand and do the work before board meeting.


===Collection of Affiliation Fees Due in 2018===
:Bailey : If there is no objection, we won't proceed to a vote.


<div id="magicdomid111" class=""><span class="">Collection of Affiliation Fees Due in 2018</span></div><div id="magicdomid112" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/403</span></div><div id="magicdomid113" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Speaker : Mike</span></span></div>
:No objections


:MichalGill: As I said before. I'm on it but I'm really busy actually.
:Mike is in charge of sending the email to Marketa.  


===Providing Invoices for Payments===


<div id="magicdomid115" class=""><span class="">Providing Invoices for Payments</span></div><div id="magicdomid116" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/405</span></div><div id="magicdomid117" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Speaker : Mike</span></span></div>
*Member mailing lists
:Ray: I am forming a standing committee that will deal with this in the long term.  


:MichalGill: I received the last year template. I've to fix it for 2018 fees.
*Finances
:Ray: No report expected as we just starting working as a board. We need to watch our economy and to report to the board the state of our finances regulary.
:Mike : I do not have acces to the accounts yet. But next meeting, I'll try to have a short report next week.
:Bailey : Do you have access to the bank informations?
:Mike : Keith is helping me on that matter.  


===Affiliation fees that are due to be paid before the end of 2019===
*Affiliation fees
:Letter from our Treasurer about final collection under old rules of 2017 (due in 2018)
:Instructions about the new rules for the members about 2018 (due in 2019)


<div id="magicdomid119" class=""><span class="">Affiliation fees that are due to be paid before the end of 2019</span></div><div id="magicdomid120" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/404</span></div><div id="magicdomid121" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Speaker : Mike</span></span></div>
*E-mail concerning the affiliation fees:


:MichalGill: As I said before. I'm on it but I'm really busy actually.
Dear Pirate friends,


===Budget===
At the last meeting of the Board of PPI elected me to be the new Treasurer. As such, it is now my responsibility, among other things, to oversee collection of affiliation fees. Therefore, I'm sending you this e-mail with three requests:


<div id="magicdomid123" class=""><span class="">Budget</span></div><div id="magicdomid124" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/391</span></div><div id="magicdomid125" class=""><br><span class=""><span class="">Also update balances from cashiers.</span></span></div><div class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Speaker : Mike</span></span></div><div id="magicdomid126" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div>
1) Affiliation fees that are due to paid before the end of 2018


:RayJohansen: I propose this item be called Budgets, plural.
As the year is now nearing to its end, I would like to ask you, if its in your party's financial means, to pay the affiliation fees for the past year. These fees were calculated according to the old system. The amount owed can be found in the column named "50€^HDI = Basic" in the last table on this link: https://wiki.pp-international.net/wiki/index.php?title=Affiliation_fees (for example in the case of Austria these fees 32.90 €). The only two parties that have already paid for 2017 are Germany and the Czech Republic, to whom go my thanks. Please note that these fees are referred to as 2017, as we collect fees the following year.
:The board needs to be presented with and formalize the following:
:Budget 2019
:Quarterly budget 2019
:Liquidity budget 2019 (sometimes referred to as cash flow budget)
:Quarterly Liquidity budget 2019
:In addition, the board needs to decide on what we demand in the form of financial reports for each board meeting. I think this should be its own point: Reporting


===Cashiers===
Affiliation fee payments can be made by the following means:
1) Bank transfer, Pirate Parties International, Case postale 36, 1188 Gimel IBAN:
CH63 0900 0000 8901 9371 7 BIC: POFICHBEXXX Geneve, Switzerland


<div id="magicdomid129" class=""><span class="">Cashiers</span></div><div id="magicdomid130" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/337</span></div><div class=""><br><span class=""><span class="">We have a retiring cashier.</span></span></div><div class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Speaker : Guillaume</span></span></br>
2) Bitcoin Exchange transfer, AA93 N84G Z6LC C7VQ kraken.com
Key: Fd8AUrJOTFtSv+qUQu6nXo4Rn8q83oqvHlP1sng/s832KHLl2X2DVmKj


:keithgoldstein: Rudulph is retiring.
3) PayPal https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=9RZ3VNM7NE7HC
:We have a conflict of interest with the other cashier that became Lay Auditors.  
:Guillaume will find to people and we'll have to nominated here.


==3. ADMINISTRATION==
2) Affiliation fees that are due to be paid before the end of 2019


<div>Items under this point : <br></div><div><ul><li>Rules of procedures</li><li>Members</li><li>Monthly outreach meeting</li><li>Tools<br></li></ul></div></span>
As the PPI nearly constantly operates with a backlog of unpaid fees on the income side of the budget, I wish to start early by announcing the fees due for next year. If the means of your party allow, please, do try to send the fees as soon as you can during the 2019, it will surely help us. Thank you. The last General Assembly introduced (on Nov 10th of this year) a new model of calculating the fees, so here it is:


===Rules of procedure===
- Mature members should pay 1000 euros. (Mature members are established members that also receive regular state funding, have elected officials at state or regional level, and/or have elected officials at local level who receive compensation; fulfilling at least two criteria.)


<div>Items under this point : <br></div><div><ul><li>Change to Board RoP #1 - Deleting §5 - point 3</li><li>Change to Board RoP #2 - Adding minimum criteria for agenda items<br></li></ul></div>
- Established members should pay 185 euros. (Established members are emerging members that also have paying members and run for elections on a regular basis.)


====Change to Board RoP # 1 - Deleting §5 - point 3====
- Emerging members should pay 50 euros. (Emerging members are nascent members that also collect donations.)


<div id="magicdomid176" class=""><span class="">Proposal for board meeting: Change to Board RoP # 1 - Deleting §5 - point 3</span></div><div id="magicdomid177" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/394</span></div><div id="magicdomid178" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span class="">We were supposed to have a rule addition to clarify the rules after removing this rule.</span></div><div id="magicdomid179" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span class="">Person in charge : Gregory and Ray</span></div>
- Nascent members would pay 0 euros. (Nascent members have regular statutory activities, such as general assemblies and run activism projects.)


:RayJohansen: This has been resolved and does not need to be in the agenda. But someone should edit the wiki to reflect the boards decision.
In addition, an optional 2% cap of the national party's budget was introduced, meaning for example that if the 2018 income of a party was 10.000€, and it otherwise would fall under the "Mature" category, that party can opt to pay only 200€. In case your party plans to opt for the 2% cap, please contact me so I can approve your party's budget information.
:RayJohansen: Someone "suggested" there was a need for clarification of the rules after removing this. There is no need for clarification. The a board decision is from now on made by a simple majority. Which is more than half of quorum.  
:keithgoldstein: I think there is a need, because now it states "Decisions are taken by a majority of board members present at the meeting."
:RayJohansen: We need to change the rules on the wiki. If that constitutes a problem that I'm not aware of please explain.
:keithgoldstein: We still have the possibility to take decision with only three members persons.  
:RayJohansen: Okay, so we need to have to make a new proposition for the next meeting.
:keithgoldstein: So now we only need 3 votes still for a board decision. A further rule is required that we will need to propose for the next board meeting.


====Change to Board RoP # 2 - Adding minimum criteria for agenda items====
3) Updating contact information


<div id="magicdomid181" class=""><span class="">Proposal for board meeting: Change to Board RoP # 2 - Adding minimum criteria for agenda items</span></div><div id="magicdomid182" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/395</span></div><div id="magicdomid183" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span class="">Discuss criteria and programs that must correlate, Redmine, Congressus.</span></div><div class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span class="">Person in charge : none
Finally, every member party of the PPI is listed in our contact list with certain contact details. We have a problem that these contact details often become obsolate as party leaders and emails change. I would therefore like to ask you to send me the following current information:


:RayJohansen: This was postponed to include more proposals for changes by Gregory Engels. It does not need to be in this agenda and is postponed until such a time Gregory is finished with his work.
- primary contact email to which you'll receive all communications from the PPI
:keithgoldstein:
- primary telephone
:keithgoldstein: We wait to discuss this topic until a later date.
- current postal address (if available)
{{CC|Topic is postponed until the next meeting. }}
- link to your party's homepage
- social media accounts (FB and Twitter, or other relevant contact)
- emails of members who should be included in our Pirate Leaders email list


===Members===
If you'd like to provide additional backup contacts, I will also be most grateful.


<div>Items under this point : <br></div><div><ul><li>Inventory of PPI members and pirates parties</li><li>Nonmember Contact<br></li></ul></div>
Thank you for your support,


====Inventory of PPI members and pirates parties====
Michal Gill
Treasurer of PPI


<div id="magicdomid206" class=""><span class="">Inventory of PPI members and pirates parties</span></div><div id="magicdomid207" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/366</span></div><div id="magicdomid208" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Person in charge : Ray</span></span></div>
:Comment from Ray: I see no problem in asking for contact information in this mail. It should be done almost every time we are in touch with our members. The Standing committee I am preparing will end up with us being able to send them a link to update their own data themselves.
:Etienne : It's fine for me
:Bailey : Me too
:Keith: Should we include the third part of contact information in this email? About affiliation fees?
:Mike: I'd say so, so collecting of the fees is not impeded by slow collection of information by other means (the work group for that). Since I'm sending the e-mail, there's no reason for not asking for main contact e-mail.
:Bailey : If there is not objections, we won't proceed to a vote.
:Mike : please check the tiers part to see if it is understandable
:Ray : General comment. I do not want to spend my meeting to read email. The two examples from today do not need review during a meeting. Email project may be share outside the meeting for review. Only controversial email have to be reviewed during Board Meeting.


:RayJohansen: This is an old thing that has been at 100 % for quite some time. For the next board meeting a project that aims to describe a plan to make tech for member administration - will be presented. It will not happen in this meeting.
*Fundraising
:keithgoldstein: There is a working group, which can be dismissed as resolved and moved to the working group.
:Nothing to report.  


====Nonmember Contact====
*GA feedback survey
:Keith will prepare one in LimeSurvey. Please consider ideas of questions we should ask.


<div id="magicdomid210" class=""><span class="">Nonmember Contact</span></div><div id="magicdomid211" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/366</span></div><div id="magicdomid212" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span class="">Announcement of full observer membership interest from Chile, make sure that we get all applications from interested parties as soon as possible.</span></div><div id="magicdomid213" class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class=""><br></span></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Person in charge : Keith</span></span></div>
*Members meeting
:First one will happen January 19th and then the 3rd Saturday of each month going forward; 8 PM CET on Mumble
:Mike: Mumble? (Yes) (beurk +1)
:Bailey : Mumble for now and we'll see if we need to change later.


:keithgoldstein: Chile contacts us. Some parties express that they want to join the PPI. If some party contacts you please don't wait to long before to help them complete their application.
: Motion passed/failed


===Monthly outreach meeting===
==6 AOB - Any other business==


<div id="magicdomid189" class=""><span class="">Monthly outreach meeting</span></div><div id="magicdomid190" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/379</span></div><div id="magicdomid191" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Person in charge : Bailey</span></span></div>
* IT Cost
:Mike : There's a conversation in Discord chat on the topic of IT cost
:Ray : We had a conversation on Wire about the IT costs.
:Cedric : I'd like to be in the loop about IT cost. (We will bring everyone in on it, but I have noted your special interest. ;=))


:RayJohansen: This does not belong in the agenda. When, and only when, Bailey decides to present a plan for the meetings it will be on the agenda again. (IMHO)
*Business cards
:Nothing to report


===Tools===
:===================================================


<div>Items under this point : <br></div><div><ul><li>Board Decision, Tasks, Voting Organization Tool</li><li>Board meeting location : test Discord</li><li>Updating Decisions of the Board on our wiki<br></li></ul></div>
Next Meeting: Monday, 12-17-2018 at 21:00 CEST (20:00 UTC) ON DISCORD !
Meeting Closed: 21:56 CEST (20:56 UTC)


====Board Decision, Tasks, Voting Organization Tool====
<noinclude> [[Category:PPI:Minutes]] </noinclude>
 
<div id="magicdomid104" class=""><span class="">Board Decision, Tasks, Voting Organization Tool</span></div><div id="magicdomid105" class=""><span class=""></span><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/398</span></div><div id="magicdomid106" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span class="">Discussion of continuation to update using which programs and where to include what.</span></div><div class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class=""><span class="">Person in charge</span></span></span> : None</span><br></span></div>
 
:RayJohansen: We are in the middle of a test of one of several tools. We do not need to discuss this in this meeting, IMHO. It does not need to be in the agenda until such a time the item is proposed again. I will do so after the tests are done. When we do make a decision on this the reasons for our choices must be made clear in supporting documents that must be written. This is especially true when we choose non-open source solutions.
 
====Board meeting location : test Discord====
 
<div id="magicdomid95" class=""><span class="">Proposal for board meeting: Board meeting location : test Discord</span></div><div id="magicdomid96" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/396</span></div><div id="magicdomid97" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class=""><span class="">Person in charge</span></span></span> : Etienne</span></span></div>
 
:RayJohansen: We are now testing it. There is no need to discuss it in this board meeting.
 
====Updating Decisions of the Board on our Wiki====
 
<div id="magicdomid142" class=""><span class="">Updating Decisions of the Board on our Wiki</span></div><div id="magicdomid143" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/401</span></div><div id="magicdomid144" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Person in charge : Keith and Thomas</span></span></div>
 
:keithgoldstein: https://wiki.pp-international.net/wiki/index.php?title=PPI_Board/Decisions_of_Board&action=edit&redlink=1
:keithgoldstein: We are updating the decisions. We could use help. Please help, pick some minutes.
:keithgoldstein: I've done the first board from 2010. It's a lot of work. Any help is welcome. Just choose one meeting and work !
 
==4. COMMUNICATION==
 
<div>Items under this point : <br></div><div><ul><li>PPI Newsletter</li><li>Article On Using Online Democracy Tools</li><li>Video Campaign <br></li></ul></div>
 
===PPI Newsletter===
 
<div id="magicdomid150" class=""><span class="">PPI Newsletter</span></div><div id="magicdomid151" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/388</span></div><div id="magicdomid152" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Person in charge : Bailey and Keith</span></span></div>
 
:RayJohansen: I do not see the need to discuss this in the meeting. We have discussed it and had it on the agenda since forever. Non of those times has a description of the task been made. In addition no person in charge of it has been found. Some say we should have a newsletter, (but what a news letter is has not been formulatet), while some contend that we do not need a new thing when we have trouble writing things for the things we already have. Wordpress, Facebook, Twitter and emails.
 
===Article on Using Online Democracy Tools===
 
<div id="magicdomid185" class=""><span class="">Article on Using Online Democracy Tools</span></div><div id="magicdomid186" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/380</span></div><div id="magicdomid187" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Person in charge : Guillaume</span></span></div>
 
{{CC|No updates. }}
:keithgoldstein: Please keep in mind, you can write article ! Any participation is welcomed.
:BaileyL: If you want to write about anything, make a video go !
 
===Video Campaign===
 
<div id="magicdomid197" class=""><span class="">Video Campaign</span></div><div id="magicdomid198" class=""><span class=""></span><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/377</span></div><div id="magicdomid199" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Person in charge : Ray</span></span></div>
 
==5. ECOSOC==
 
<div>Items under this point : <br></div><div><ul><li>Requestion for Inputs</li><li>Annual Membership Passes for UNHQ - New-York<br></li></ul></div><div><br></div>
===Request for Inputs===
 
<div id="magicdomid138" class=""><span class="">Request for Inputs to 10th session of the General Assembly’s Open-ended Working Group on Ageing</span></div><div id="magicdomid139" class=""><span class=""></span><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/402</span></div><div id="magicdomid140" class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class=""><br></span></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Person in charge : Keith</span></span></div>
 
:keithgoldstein: This a very important task. The dead line is February 1st. All the details are in the Redmine task. Please join.
 
===Annual Membership Passes for UNHQ - New York===
 
<div id="magicdomid146" class=""><span class="">Annual Membership Passes for UNHQ - New York</span></div><div id="magicdomid147" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/384</span></div><div id="magicdomid148" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Person in charge : Keith</span></span></div>
 
:keithgoldstein: Please nominate people from Geneva, from N-Y (and Vienna).
 
==4. CONFERENCES==
 
<div>Items under this point : <br></div><div><ul><li>Pirate Security Conference</li><li>Think Twice #4<br></li></ul></div>
 
===PCS===
 
<div>Item under this point : <br></div><div><ul><li>Proposal for agenda item : Pirate Security Conference - Discussion</li></ul></div>
 
====Proposal for agenda item: Pirate Security Conference - discussion====
 
<div id="magicdomid161" class=""><span class="">Proposal for agenda item: Pirate Security Conference - discussion</span></div><div id="magicdomid162" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/392</span></div><div id="magicdomid163" class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class=""><br></span></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Person in charge : Ray, Bailey, Keith</span></span></div><div id="magicdomid164" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span class="">Here is a discussion of the meeting that we had on 12/13</span></div><div id="magicdomid165" class=""><span class=" url">https://etherpad.pp-international.net/p/psc-meeting-dec-14-pv9b03v</span></div><div id="magicdomid166" class=""><span class=""><Please add announcements from pad></span></div>
 
:RayJohansen: This agenda item was resolved. A discussion happened and was acted on. Things were clarified.
:AFTER budgets have been formalized we will then see IF we have the cash flow to give 400 euros to PSC. But that is for a new item when we can do it.
:RayJohansen: On a sidenote. There can only be one person in charge. Many may participate but there cannot be more than one "Person in Charge"
:BaileyL: We attended the organization meeting. It was really good. We got an idea how they handle this and how PPI can help. Our role is not clear, but we might help with social media communication.
:keithgoldstein: They are thinking about having a PPI speaker in the event to speak on behalf of the movement.
 
===TT4===
 
<div>Item under this point : <br></div><div>Proposal for Board meeting : Think Twice #4  - Discussion</div>
 
====Proposal for board meeting: Think Twice #4 - discussion====
 
<div id="magicdomid169" class=""><span class="">Proposal for board meeting: Think Twice #4 - discussion</span></div><div id="magicdomid170" class=""><span class=" url">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/393</span></div><div id="magicdomid171" class=""><span class=""><br></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Person in charge : Ladislav, Mike, Keith and Koen</span></span></div><div id="magicdomid172" class=""><br></div>
 
:RayJohansen: This was resolved. There was a discussion where it was clarified a plan including budget must be penned and presented to the board who only then can decide IF we will run the conference. (There should be only one person in charge, although many might be listed as participants.)
:MichalGill: The information is in the hand of the PPCZ board. We have to wait.
:keithgoldstein: Koen said that he'll working on the website. We have to set up a working group for coordination.
:RayJohansen: Point of order : Please remove this two points of order. If there are any news, put up new agenda items. This two have been resolved.
 
==6. STATUES REVISION==
 
<div>Item under this point : <br></div><div><ul><li>Subgroup for revamping the language of the PPI Statutes<br></li></ul></div>
 
===Subgroup for revamping the language of the PPI statutes===
 
<div id="magicdomid154" class=""><span class="">Subgroup for revamping the language of the PPI statutes</span></div><div id="magicdomid155" class="">https://redmine.pp-international.net/issues/376</span></div><div id="magicdomid156" class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class=""><br></span></span></div><div class=""><span style="font-weight: bold;"><span class="">Person in charge : Etienne, Guillaume, Keith</span></span></div>
 
:Etienne: This point is not relevant because we decided to set up a new process.
 
==AOB - Any other business==
 
:keithgoldstein: There is a huge project for fund raising : register to the state of Geneva but it's a lot of work.
:RayJohansen: We starts to use Congressus and Discord. it's really impressing. It's well organize... I'm ready to call it a huge success. It only gets better. It can helps us to work in a more professional way.
:I want to thank Bailey for this really good first meeting.
:I want to the French members for this tool
:BaileyL: It is an awesome tool... Thank you to Cédric and Etienne for the tool, and Bastian.
:The raise hand helps me.
 
==NEXT MEETING==
 
Next meeting : Sunday 30th - 9PM CET</br>
 
:RayJohansen: Suggestion: Sunday December 30th 17:00 CET
:RayJohansen: Thomas
:Forget the 30th. Skip to 07.01.
:14:00 CET
:Make it Sund. the 14th
{{CC|The 30th meeting is skip. }}
:RayJohansen: Chair sees the opportunities and just invites if no objections are given.
{{CC|Decided date : Mon. 14th January - 21:00 CET
Where ? On the French Discord}}
 
=Ayant participé à un vote=
 
* 9 - MichalGill
* 5 - BaileyL
* 6 - RayJohansen
* 3 - Etienne
* 4 - keithgoldstein

Latest revision as of 07:38, 17 January 2019

Agenda PPI BOARD MEETING
--- [12/02/21:00]h CEST ---
Mumble: mumble.piratenpartei-nrw.de
Room: "/international/pirate parties international/board meeting"
Audio recording:
Video:

Record of the meeting

1 - ATTENDEES

1.1 - Members of the PPI board

participating: Bailey, Ray, Mike, Keith, Etienne, Ladislav
excused:
unexcused:

1.2 - Others

Alternate Board Members
participating: Cédric Levieux, Kitty
excused:
unexcused:
Guests
participating:Koen

2 - PROCEEDINGS

RoP: http://wiki.pp-international.net/PPI_Board/Rules_of_Procedure
Meeting opened at 21:08 CEST by Bailey
Meeting chaired by Bailey
Secretary for this meeting is Etienne
Quorum established with 6 out of 7 board members present.
Streaming started: not possible
Recording started: No record, the bot is down. We are running test on Discord.
Postal votes:
Notes on meeting process
  • [HH:MM] CEST: (name) entered the meeting [=> Quorum not established with X out of Y board members]
  • [HH:MM] CEST: (name) left the meeting [=> Quorum established with X out of Y board members]
  • [HH:MM] x-minute break by initiated by (name)
Meeting closed at HH:MM CEST by (name)

3 - APPROVAL ON THE MINUTES

  • Minutes of the last meeting
https://wiki.pp-international.net/wiki/index.php?title=PPI_Minutes_2018_11_19
YES: Ray, Etienne, Bailey, Mike, Kitty, Ladislav
NO:
ABSTENTIONS:
Minutes approved? Minutes approved
Ray : Keith signaled that Kitty should vote on his behalf because he is not able to do so.
Bailey : Ok noted on the minutes

4 - REPORTS

4.1 - Short report of the board members 1)

  • Board:
  • Guillaume: absent
  • Bailey: Rico Brouwer from the Utrecht Pirate Party (PPNL) approached Ray and I about PPI collaborating on a project with them. The project is about political prisoners in Catalonia and raising awareness about their trials in January 2019...if you've been following the situation there, you probably know that a lot of activists and elected officials from Catalonia have faced repression and imprisonment by the Spanish government for holding an independence referendum. This is not about anyone's stance on Catalan independence but about the right to self-determination. The point is to use the global Pirate network to spread information that the media is largely ignoring. We published Rico's message to all Pirates on our website: https://pp-international.net/2018/11/call-to-action-dutch-pirates-challenge-the-international-community-to-promote-the-plight-of-catalan-political-prisoners/
  • Keith: Working on our working groups for affiliation fees and conferences, i am also trying to prepare a grant request through unhq. I am hoping to hear more about grants from unog that guillaume and bjorn should update us on. Also, i plan to attend the psc meeting sometime soon and wait to hear about that from alex kohler.
  • Ladislav: Had TT4 discussion with Keith and Mike; started steps towards participations of PPI in the next ECOSOC meeting (mid Februrary 2019) - registration by January 2019.
  • Mike: Worked wth Keith and Ladislav on the TT4 proposition for the PPCZ board, along with other tasks on the same subject (Keith's work group), and an e-mail draft for our members concerning the affiliation fees (my work group) both will be dealt with in detail below. Also introduced by Keith to the intricacies of being a treasurer and to all the tables and pages on the topic. :-)
  • Etienne : The Rules of procedures for the Statutes Revision Standing committee are ready. I'll prepare an e-mail for the pp-leaders asking to register their delegates before the end of the month.The goal is to organize the first meeting before the 15th of January. The date will be imposed for this first meeting and after we'll set up a calendar according to the geofraphical situation of the delegates. The goal is to use meeting only to finalize the asynchronous discussions that will be hold on Discourse and (I hope) on Congressus too.

--> https://docs.google.com/document/d/13Aru7Qf9VxRFqsz4JziOw7B682d1_O97_tWWRC5okg8/edit?usp=sharing New contact email for PPFR : international[at]partipirate.org

  • Alternates:
  • Daniel : Absent
  • Gregory: Absent
  • Kitty Nothing to report at this time.
  • Cédric Levieux : Waiting from Bastian for some credential on the Congressus VM, we miss the pgp key ciphering process (wrong/old key used). Communication problem, that's all.

5 - Proposal No. 1

  • Updates from Working Groups
    • PSC
Bailey and Keith are waiting for the meeting invitation from the PSC team. We were told that we would hear about this at the beginning of December so it should be any day now.
Keith : Go PSC. I also heard that the deadline for submissions to speak at psc will probably be extended. So there is still time to make submissions.
    • TT4
Letter from PPI to PPCZ
Current Proposal of the Letter

"Dear Board of the Czech Pirate Party,

We propose the continuation of the Think Twice Conference (TT4) to take place in Prague during the fall of 2019. Initial brainstorming discussions were held with relevant stakeholders, and there is positive feedback about this proposal. This letter represents an informal proposal to be approved by your board, which will allow us to commence planning of the event. Please feel free to share this document with your colleagues, as we wish to collaborate and receive feedback about structuring this event. The ideas presented below represent our initial pitch, and we will revise them accordingly. The following letter includes notes from the brainstorming session conducted by our current initial committee, which is composed of requests for support.

I. Planning Committee: We plan to establish a committee with three subcommittees (below) to spearhead the organization of the event. We encourage the Czech Pirate Party to spread the word amongst its members to join the Planning Committee.

Within the committee we will require three subcommittees: 1) The academic committee, 2) The technical support group, and 3) The logistics team

1) The academic committee will review submissions, decide on which submissions are accepted, provide written correspondence to speakers, moderate panel discussions, and organize the written submissions into publishable proceedings.

2) The technical support group will be in charge of recording equipment, streaming the conference online, setting up microphones, speakers, etc.,

3) The logistics team will coordinate human resources, fundraising, finances, press releases, translations, the details such as name tags, and all other matters to facilitate a smooth conference.

The following people are the current Committe Members on behalf of the PPI: Michal Gill, Ladislav Koubek, Keith Goldstein, Gregory Engels, Koen De Voegt

II. Content: We request recommendations about content, which will be debated by the TT4 Planning Committee in conjunction with the boards of PPCZ and PPI.

III. Facilities: We are considering the venue and facilities necessary for this event. We consider using the new Pirate Center opened in downtown Prague, which could be used for the smaller events (capacity approx 60-80 people). As in previous TT events, we are also considering a large one day event that will be open to the public, which would be held at a larger venue or public space that should be arranged. Considerations about the venues will be made in line with the initial financing procured for the event, along with the number of registrations received for speakers and attendees. (Ladislav: Keith, Mike I would like to speak with you regarding the wording of this paragraph prior to Mike sending it.)

We would appreciate any input on the topics mentioned in this letter and above all, we hope for your general approval of the event to even take place in your country. We are convinced that an established international conference of this kind will benefit both the Czech Pirate Party as well as the PPI.

Sincerely,

The Board of PPI"

Ray: So, I don't think board are the place to do working on wordings. We should ready the document before hand and do the work before board meeting.
Bailey : If there is no objection, we won't proceed to a vote.
No objections
Mike is in charge of sending the email to Marketa.


  • Member mailing lists
Ray: I am forming a standing committee that will deal with this in the long term.
  • Finances
Ray: No report expected as we just starting working as a board. We need to watch our economy and to report to the board the state of our finances regulary.
Mike : I do not have acces to the accounts yet. But next meeting, I'll try to have a short report next week.
Bailey : Do you have access to the bank informations?
Mike : Keith is helping me on that matter.
  • Affiliation fees
Letter from our Treasurer about final collection under old rules of 2017 (due in 2018)
Instructions about the new rules for the members about 2018 (due in 2019)
  • E-mail concerning the affiliation fees:

Dear Pirate friends,

At the last meeting of the Board of PPI elected me to be the new Treasurer. As such, it is now my responsibility, among other things, to oversee collection of affiliation fees. Therefore, I'm sending you this e-mail with three requests:

1) Affiliation fees that are due to paid before the end of 2018

As the year is now nearing to its end, I would like to ask you, if its in your party's financial means, to pay the affiliation fees for the past year. These fees were calculated according to the old system. The amount owed can be found in the column named "50€^HDI = Basic" in the last table on this link: https://wiki.pp-international.net/wiki/index.php?title=Affiliation_fees (for example in the case of Austria these fees 32.90 €). The only two parties that have already paid for 2017 are Germany and the Czech Republic, to whom go my thanks. Please note that these fees are referred to as 2017, as we collect fees the following year.

Affiliation fee payments can be made by the following means: 1) Bank transfer, Pirate Parties International, Case postale 36, 1188 Gimel IBAN: CH63 0900 0000 8901 9371 7 BIC: POFICHBEXXX Geneve, Switzerland

2) Bitcoin Exchange transfer, AA93 N84G Z6LC C7VQ kraken.com Key: Fd8AUrJOTFtSv+qUQu6nXo4Rn8q83oqvHlP1sng/s832KHLl2X2DVmKj

3) PayPal https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=9RZ3VNM7NE7HC

2) Affiliation fees that are due to be paid before the end of 2019

As the PPI nearly constantly operates with a backlog of unpaid fees on the income side of the budget, I wish to start early by announcing the fees due for next year. If the means of your party allow, please, do try to send the fees as soon as you can during the 2019, it will surely help us. Thank you. The last General Assembly introduced (on Nov 10th of this year) a new model of calculating the fees, so here it is:

- Mature members should pay 1000 euros. (Mature members are established members that also receive regular state funding, have elected officials at state or regional level, and/or have elected officials at local level who receive compensation; fulfilling at least two criteria.)

- Established members should pay 185 euros. (Established members are emerging members that also have paying members and run for elections on a regular basis.)

- Emerging members should pay 50 euros. (Emerging members are nascent members that also collect donations.)

- Nascent members would pay 0 euros. (Nascent members have regular statutory activities, such as general assemblies and run activism projects.)

In addition, an optional 2% cap of the national party's budget was introduced, meaning for example that if the 2018 income of a party was 10.000€, and it otherwise would fall under the "Mature" category, that party can opt to pay only 200€. In case your party plans to opt for the 2% cap, please contact me so I can approve your party's budget information.

3) Updating contact information

Finally, every member party of the PPI is listed in our contact list with certain contact details. We have a problem that these contact details often become obsolate as party leaders and emails change. I would therefore like to ask you to send me the following current information:

- primary contact email to which you'll receive all communications from the PPI - primary telephone - current postal address (if available) - link to your party's homepage - social media accounts (FB and Twitter, or other relevant contact) - emails of members who should be included in our Pirate Leaders email list

If you'd like to provide additional backup contacts, I will also be most grateful.

Thank you for your support,

Michal Gill Treasurer of PPI

Comment from Ray: I see no problem in asking for contact information in this mail. It should be done almost every time we are in touch with our members. The Standing committee I am preparing will end up with us being able to send them a link to update their own data themselves.
Etienne : It's fine for me
Bailey : Me too
Keith: Should we include the third part of contact information in this email? About affiliation fees?
Mike: I'd say so, so collecting of the fees is not impeded by slow collection of information by other means (the work group for that). Since I'm sending the e-mail, there's no reason for not asking for main contact e-mail.
Bailey : If there is not objections, we won't proceed to a vote.
Mike : please check the tiers part to see if it is understandable
Ray : General comment. I do not want to spend my meeting to read email. The two examples from today do not need review during a meeting. Email project may be share outside the meeting for review. Only controversial email have to be reviewed during Board Meeting.
  • Fundraising
Nothing to report.
  • GA feedback survey
Keith will prepare one in LimeSurvey. Please consider ideas of questions we should ask.
  • Members meeting
First one will happen January 19th and then the 3rd Saturday of each month going forward; 8 PM CET on Mumble
Mike: Mumble? (Yes) (beurk +1)
Bailey : Mumble for now and we'll see if we need to change later.
Motion passed/failed

6 AOB - Any other business

  • IT Cost
Mike : There's a conversation in Discord chat on the topic of IT cost
Ray : We had a conversation on Wire about the IT costs.
Cedric : I'd like to be in the loop about IT cost. (We will bring everyone in on it, but I have noted your special interest. ;=))
  • Business cards
Nothing to report
===================================================

Next Meeting: Monday, 12-17-2018 at 21:00 CEST (20:00 UTC) ON DISCORD ! Meeting Closed: 21:56 CEST (20:56 UTC)